12/11/14, "Won’t allow progress review, India tells UN climate meet," Times of India, Vishwa Mohan, Lima, Peru
"Opposing one of the key components of the negotiations which is being
strongly pushed by all European Union (EU) countries and civil society,
India on Tuesday categorically told the climate conference that the
country will not allow any outside body to review progress of its
"intended" targets/measures as these will be "nationally determined"
Making India's stand amply clear on the issue of
"progress review", Indian environment and climate change minister
Prakash Javadekar said, "We do not see any role for any ex-ante review
in this process".
China and most of the developing countries have the same view on the issue.
Interestingly, the EU and US are not on the same page on this issue.
While EU wants review of countries' actions, the US takes a middle path,
saying the important issue is to encourage countries to be ambitious
with their targets.
Referring to the contentious issue of
adding the "progress review" Javadekar, however, said, "We firmly believe
that the INDCs are to be 'nationally determined'. We do not see any
role for any ex-ante review in this process. The INDCs should include
all elements including mitigation, adaptation, finance, technology and
Civil societies and research groups have,
however, opposed India's stand. The New Delhi-based Centre for Science
and Environment (CSE) has termed the Javadekar's statement that India
would not support ex-ante review of the Intended Nationally Determined
Contribution (INDCs) — as 'regressive'.
"Review of INDCs is one
of ways in which the principles of equity and common but differentiated
responsibility and respective capability can be brought back into the
climate change negotiations. But India is neither supporting the review
nor proposing any alternative mechanism", said Chandra Bhushan, deputy
director general of CSE.
Bhushan, who is attending the climate
conference here in Lima as observer, cited an example. He said,
"Presently, there is no provision to hold countries like the US
accountable, which is proposing just 12-14% emissions reduction by 2025
from 1990 levels"
Calling Lima negotiations as "COP of Hope",
the minister, however, added the conditions which may guide India on the
path to an "ambitious, comprehensive and equitable agreement at Paris
Enlisting those conditions as his country's
position during the negotiations, the minister said, "It should be able
to address the genuine requirements of the developing countries by
providing them equitable carbon space to achieve sustainable development
and eradicate poverty.
"The new agreement is under the
convention (UNFCCC). Let us be clear, it is the second commitment period
of the Kyoto Protocol that is ending in 2020, not the convention.
Adherence to the principles and provisions of the Convention is the
He emphasized that the "beautiful balance of collective
action — the principles of equity and common but differentiated
responsibilities (CBDRs) — should form the basis of continued action. It
is equally evident that developing countries could do more if finance,
technology support and capacity building is ensured. This must be a key
focus of the new agreement".
The remarks come at a time when
the rich nations are trying to dilute the provisions of the CBDRs which
are ingrained in the principles of the UNFCCC and its Kyoto Protocal.
Showing a mirror to developed countries by bringing the pre-2020 period
to the fore, he said, "Our ambition in the post-2020 period is directly
linked with ambitious actions in the pre-2020 period by the developed
countries, otherwise the poor people in developing countries will not
get the carbon space to achieve sustainable development.
believe that the global warming threat is real, then we must deliver on
the agreed commitments as a matter of priority. It is important
therefore for developed country parties to urgently fulfill their legal
obligations in the pre-2020 period. They must scale up their mitigation
ambition now and urgently fulfill their promises for providing financial
and technological support to developing countries".
contentious issue of including adaptation goal in the treaty, he said,
"Adaptation is a central and critical priority for developing countries
to address Climate Change. The new post-2020 agreement should ensure a
balance between mitigation and adaptation. The urgent need for
adaptation must be fully reflected in the new agreement."
his intervention on Green Climate Fund during the talks, Javadekar also
pitched for bigger kitty of climate finance from the developed world.
He said developing countries need for mitigation and adaptation was
being estimated in the range of $600 billion to $1500 billion ($1.5 trillion) per year
(by 2050). He enlisted India's ongoing adaptation measures and
emphasized on making "adaptation" goal as part of the future global
He also focused on the reluctance of the rich nations
to contribute to the Green Climate Fund. "Some announcements have been
made by some countries to contribute to the Green Climate Fund. However,
the scale of these announcements remains far from what has been
pledged", he said in reference to the goal of 100 billion dollars in the
So far, the rich nations have collectively contributed
slightly over 10 billion dollars as against the overall goal of 100
billion dollars till 2020 and 100 billion dollars per year beyond 2020.
Belgium on Tuesday pledged to contribute more than 50 million Euros
(around $62 million US) to the Green Climate Fund, edging the fund past
its 10 billion dollars goal for 2014. Australia, which has been the most
reluctant contributor, also pledged 166 million US dollars to the GCF.
In his speech, the minister also enlisted all the measures which are
being taken by India to move on to the low carbon growth path to fight
challenges of climate change."
Comment: US taxpayer dollars given by US politicians to other governments or to the UN can easily end up in personal Swiss Bank accounts.
News that doesn't receive the necessary attention.
- ► 2017 (454)
- ► 2016 (1320)
- ► 2015 (661)
- Cold temperature ties record in Pueblo, Colorado, ...
- Firefighters rescue 130 trapped in snow on Califor...
- 72.5% of US is under 32F. Average temperature acro...
- 97% of scientists agree, roads in Algeria blocked ...
- Pope Francis Errs in Linking Church to Green Movem...
- Historic US CO2 partner Communist China now blocks...
- Greenland Ice Sheet surface mass as of Dec. 28, 20...
- 16.7F on Christmas night in UK, many cars abandone...
- Almost $2 billion a day spent 2011 to 2012 on the ...
- One fifth of aid dollars is now diverted to climat...
- Scientific study finds people who act green experi...
- Incredibly cold weather in China causes even the Y...
- Arctic Sea Ice Extent, Dec. 21, 2014
- Club of Rome: We came up with the idea that the th...
- Japan scientist quits after government lab is unab...
- 'China Dream' was launched with yearlong spectacle...
- Fidel Castro blasted US biofuels policy as 'genoci...
- US almost CO2-free according to first images from ...
- UN's Ban Ki-Moon is negligent on climate science, ...
- New study presented at AGU doubles earlier scienti...
- Squirrels causing global warming in Arctic, diggin...
- Electric cars cause 86% more deaths from air pollu...
- Arctic sea ice volume holds up in 2014, Oct. 2014 ...
- Antarctic Sea Ice Extent, 12/13/14, NSIDC
- Lax standards of historic US CO2 partner China cau...
- Arctic Ice not missing. 12/12/14 Arctic Sea Ice ex...
- UN prevents free speech even that of Americans who...
- Christie Whitman received Lifetime Achievement Awa...
- Alaska covered with snow Dec. 12, 2014 per Rutgers...
- Richard Black: Margin of error on NOAA "hottest" c...
- A foot of new snow in Killington, Vermont, Dec. 10...
- Congratulations to unelected, unaccountable, US ta...
- India Environment Minister says India won't allow ...
- Carbon Dioxide takes back seat in Latin America wh...
- Roger Pielke Jr.'s challenge to erroneous NY Times...
- No solar panels used at UN climate conference in e...
- China dominates the world in CO2 emissions from fo...
- Record US fossil fuel exports under Obama-AP. US f...
- Historic new US CO2 partner China nixes oversight ...
- PNAS peer reviewed science finds western US land a...
- Antarctic Sea Ice Extent, Dec. 5, 2014, NSIDC. Wes...
- Arctic Sea Ice Extent, Dec. 5, 2014, NSIDC
- China pledges nothing to UN Climate Fund despite b...
- West Antarctic melting caused by subglacial volcan...
- Billboard ad in Canada insults climate science, di...
- Poverty is worst kind of environmental disaster an...
- No evidence that global warming 'pause' is ending....
- Arctic Sea Ice Extent at decade high 12/2/14, 30%+...
- Second day of needed rain in California, flooding ...
- Despite "hottest" headlines "as Lima climate talks...
- For anti-industry California, Obama CO2 deal with ...
- US greenhouse gas emissions plunge 2007-2012 per 2...
- ▼ December (52)
- ► 2013 (550)
- ► 2012 (611)
- ► 2011 (487)
- ► 2010 (337)
- ► 2009 (33)